More like Missing in Jinx Cove

anchored on:contemporarycozy mysterysmall town

but

Narrow

Witch City MysteriesSeries
series15 books2014
Cozy mystery, set in contemporary.
“Most folks associate the city of Salem, Massachusetts with witches, but for Lee Barrett, it's home.”
from the catalogue
Start with Caught Dead Handed →
Haunted Haven MysteriesSeries
series4 books2021
Cozy mystery, set in contemporary and small town.
Start with Be My Ghost →
Perfectly Proper Paranormal Museum MysteriesSeries
series6 books2016
Cozy mystery and paranormal, set in contemporary.
Start with The Perfectly Proper Paranormal Museum →
Mystic Notch Cozy MysterySeries
series7 books2014
Cozy mystery, set in contemporary and small town.
Start with Ghostly Paws →
Witch Way Librarian MysteriesSeries
series8 books2020
Cozy mystery, set in contemporary.
“Librarian Josie Way moved to small-town Oregon to lay low.”
from the catalogue
Start with Bait and Witch →
Magical Dressmaking MysterySeries
series6 books2011
Mysterious in tone, set in north america.
Start with Pleating for Mercy →