Loreful
HomeDiscover
Search series, authors…⌘K
Loreful

Reading orders for SF/F series and shared universes — with your place kept in every one.

Explore

UniversesSeriesWorksAuthorsAtlas

Help

FAQAboutSite map

Account & legal

Sign inCreate accountPrivacyTerms

Data

Built on ISFDB, Wikipedia, Wikidata and Open Library. Curated reading orders carry their reasoning on the page; the rest follow publication order. Data sources & licenses

© Loreful · data: ISFDB · CC BY

More like Reef

anchored on:science fictionspace stationfar futurespace colonization

but

Mood

The mood the book leaves you in.

  • The reading experience is propelled by journeys, exploration, and physical risk; excitement and forward momentum dominate over dread or introspection.
  • Joy and loss are deliberately mixed; the resolution grants characters something real while taking something else away, leaving warmth and sorrow together.
  • The book demands work from the reader — dense prose, difficult structure, unfamiliar ideas, or morally uncomfortable material — as part of its intended effect.
  • Grim events, cruelty, or despair dominate the atmosphere, and the book does not soften them with comfort or comic relief.
  • The atmosphere is quietly unsettling — wrongness, unease, and the uncanny pervade the book without necessarily escalating into overt horror.
  • The book is built to move the reader; character feeling is foregrounded and major scenes aim at a strong emotional response.
  • Humor is a primary aim and the prose plays for laughs — comic situations, wit, or dialogue produce sustained comedy, not occasional levity.
  • The book insists that things can improve; effort and decency are shown to matter, and the arc bends toward better outcomes even through hardship.
  • The book teaches as it goes — real facts, history, science, or craft are conveyed in enough depth that learning is part of the reading experience.
  • The book is designed to uplift and motivate, presenting perseverance or achievement in a way that invites the reader to aspire or act.
  • The overall register is cheerful and easygoing; stakes are kept gentle and the book avoids dwelling on pain or dread.
  • Withheld information drives the experience; the book sustains enigmas and secrets the reader wants resolved, whatever its genre.
  • The book is contemplative and inward-looking, giving more weight to thought, memory, and meaning than to external events.
  • The book works as comfort reading — low tension, a soothing pace, and an atmosphere the reader can unwind in.
  • Grief, loss, or melancholy set the dominant register, and the book lets sorrow stand rather than resolving it into comfort.
  • Sustained suspense is the point; the book keeps the reader braced for what happens next through danger, pressure, or impending revelation.
  • Playful invention and charm define the register — fanciful conceits, light absurdity, and a narration that delights in its own oddity.

About

What the story runs on.

  • Stories in which a machine intelligence — an AI, computer mind, or sentient program — is a central character or the story's driving problem.
  • Stories in which extraterrestrial beings are central — as characters, cultures, or the object of the plot.
  • Stories driven by deliberate modification of genomes — designer organisms, engineered humans, and the consequences of remaking life.
  • Stories about venturing into space to explore — survey missions, astronauts, and the frontier of the unknown beyond Earth.
  • Stories about minds with paranormal abilities — telepathy, telekinesis, precognition, empathy — and how societies handle those who have them.
  • Stories in which staying alive against nature, catastrophe, or scarcity is the central problem.
  • Stories of growing up — a young protagonist crossing from childhood into adult knowledge and responsibility.
  • Stories about who a character truly is — self-discovery, doubled lives, and the search for a self.
  • Stories in which belief, doubt, and religious life are the central subject, from crises of faith to life inside a religious community.
  • Stories driven by maneuvering for power — factions, conspiracies, and statecraft conducted in shadow.
  • Stories about rising against rulers — uprisings, resistance movements, and revolutions and their aftermaths.
  • Stories in which war itself is the subject — combat, occupation, and what warfare does to soldiers and civilians.

Shelf

Where it sits in the library.

    • Fiction built on magic or other supernatural elements that have no scientific explanation.
    • Secondary-world fantasy at large scale, where the fate of nations or the world turns on the protagonists' struggle.
    • Fantasy set in a recognizably modern city or contemporary world where the supernatural intrudes on everyday life.
    • Fantasy that blends in horror's atmosphere and imagery, keeping a fantastical frame around grim or frightening material.
    • Action-driven fantasy following warriors or rogues with personal stakes against sorcerous threats, rather than world-spanning conflicts.
    • Fantasy set in a real historical period or a close analogue of one, with magic woven into the era.
    • Fantasy in which protagonists cross from the ordinary world into another world through a portal or similar passage.
    • Fiction that retells or reworks a traditional fairy tale in a new form or setting.
    • Fantasy drawing directly on myths, legends, and folklore, retelling them or building on their figures and logic.
    • Fantasy of ghosts, vampires, shapeshifters, psychics, and similar phenomena, usually set in an otherwise ordinary world.
    • Fiction mixing science-fictional trappings with overtly magical or impossible elements in one setting.
    • Low-stakes fantasy emphasizing comfort, community, and everyday pleasures over conflict and peril.
    • Speculative fiction of pervasive moral ambiguity, violence, and cynicism that rejects heroic conventions — fantasy and SF alike.
      • Fiction that extrapolates from science and technology — future societies, space travel, or speculative inventions — within at least nominally natural laws.
      • Science fiction of interstellar scope — starships, galactic polities, and adventure across star systems.
      • Science fiction committed to scientific rigor, where technical plausibility constrains the story.
      • Science fiction centered on armed forces and warfare, told largely from a military point of view.
      • Science fiction of networked, corporate-dominated near futures, pairing high technology with social decay.
      • Science fiction styled on nineteenth-century steam-powered technology, often in a Victorian or pseudo-Victorian setting.
      • Fiction depicting an oppressive or catastrophic society, presented as a warning.
      • Fiction set after civilization's collapse, following survivors in the ruins of the old world.
      • Fiction in which characters move between past and future, and the mechanics or consequences of that travel drive the plot.
      • Fiction exploring a world where a historical event went differently and history diverged from ours.
      • Science fiction about humanity's first encounter and communication with an alien intelligence.
      • Science fiction in which extraterrestrial forces attack or occupy Earth and humanity resists.
      • Fiction whose primary aim is to frighten or unsettle the reader through dread, menace, or the monstrous.
      • Horror of vast, indifferent, incomprehensible entities before which humanity is insignificant, in the Lovecraft tradition.
      • Horror of decaying houses, buried family secrets, and oppressive atmosphere in the Gothic literary tradition.
      • Horror centered on hauntings and the returning dead.
      • Horror located in the mind — paranoia, obsession, and unreliable perception rather than external monsters.
      • Horror built around the reanimated dead and survival amid their outbreaks.
      • Horror defined by explicit, transgressive gore that refuses to cut away from violence.
      • Speculative fiction of the strange and uncanny that resists both natural explanation and standard genre categories.
      • Fiction organized around solving a crime or puzzle, typically following an investigator toward the identification of a culprit.
      • A puzzle-first mystery that lays out clues so the culprit's identity can be deduced before the reveal.
      • Crime fiction of moral ambiguity, fatalism, and hard-edged style, set among the corrupt and the doomed.
      • A mystery following the realistic routines of police work — forensics, interviews, and case-building.
      • A gentle mystery with an amateur sleuth, a small community, and violence kept off the page.
      • A mystery set in a past era, where the investigation works within that period's methods and society.
      • Fast-paced fiction driven by imminent danger, pursuit, or high-stakes conspiracy, built to sustain tension.
      • A thriller of espionage — agents, tradecraft, and intelligence services in conflict.
      • A thriller centered on lawyers and the courtroom, where litigation carries the suspense.
      • A thriller driven by detailed contemporary or near-future technology, often military or scientific.
      • A thriller whose tension comes from mental states and manipulation between characters rather than external action.
      • Fiction whose central plot is a romantic relationship and its development toward an emotionally satisfying resolution.
      • Romance in which one or both partners are supernatural beings, blending fantasy elements into the love story.
      • A fantasy-romance hybrid in which the romantic arc and the fantasy plot carry equal weight.
      • Romance set in a past era, with courtship shaped by the period's society and manners.
      • Romance set in the present day, without supernatural or historical elements.
      • Fiction set in a real past period, where the historical setting materially shapes characters and events.
        • General and literary fiction emphasizing prose style, character interiority, or formal ambition over genre plot conventions.
        • Fiction in a realistic world where magical events occur and are treated as ordinary, in the tradition of Latin American literature.
        • Fiction that ridicules people, institutions, or society in order to criticize them.
        • Fiction of dreamlike, irrational imagery and logic that breaks from realistic representation.
        • Fiction that plays with narrative convention through metafiction, fragmentation, and self-reference.
        • Fiction propelled by journeys, exploration, and physical peril, where action and survival carry the plot.
        • Adventure fiction of ships and seafaring — naval engagements, voyages, and life at sea.
        • Fiction of the American frontier West — gunmen, ranchers, and lawmen, typically in the late nineteenth century.
        • Fiction centered on soldiers, campaigns, and the experience of warfare, historical or imagined.
          • Fiction written primarily to amuse, using comedic situations, wit, or parody as its organizing principle.
            • Multi-generational fiction following a family or dynasty across decades, with inheritance and kinship as the through-line.
              • Fiction whose world runs on explicit game mechanics — levels, stats, and skills that characters can see and exploit.
                • Fiction about costumed or superpowered heroes and their conflicts with comparable villains.

                Practical

                How long a commitment, whether it stands alone, and whether it has finished.

                Tap a chip to ask for it · tap again to rule it out · once more to clear. Numbers show what would be left.

                • Cover of Imperial Earth
                  Imperial Earth

                  Arthur C. Clarke · standalone novel · 1975

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar futurehard science fiction

                  Imperial Earth is a science fiction novel by British writer Sir Arthur C. Clarke, published in 1975 by Gollancz Books. The plot follows the protagonist, Duncan Makenzie, on a trip to Earth from his home on Titan, in large part as a diplomatic visit to the U.S. for its quincentennial in 2276, but also to have a clone of himself produced. The book was published in time for the U.S. bicentennial in 1976.

                • Cover of Mars (Kim Stanley Robinson)
                  Mars (Kim Stanley Robinson)

                  series · 36 books · 1982

                  similar byspace colonizationscience fictionfar futurehard science fiction+1 more

                  The Mars trilogy is a series of science fiction novels by Kim Stanley Robinson that chronicles the settlement and terraforming of the planet Mars through the personal and detailed viewpoints of a wide variety of characters spanning 187 years, from 2026 to 2212. Ultimately more utopian than dystopian, the story focuses on egalitarian, sociological, and scientific advances made on Mars, while Earth suffers from overpopulation and ecological disaster.

                • Cover of 2312
                  2312

                  Kim Stanley Robinson · standalone novel · 2012

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar futurehard science fiction

                  In the eponymous year, when Earth's ecology is degraded and humanity has settled throughout the solar system by terraforming and genetic engineering, mysterious disasters strike some human communities and an assortment of human types from throughout the system seek to find and eliminate the cause.

                • Cover of The Songs of Distant Earth
                  The Songs of Distant Earth

                  Arthur C. Clarke · standalone novel · 1986

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar futurehard science fiction

                  The Songs of Distant Earth is a 1986 science fiction novel by British writer Arthur C. Clarke, based upon his 1958 short story of the same title. Of all of his novels, Clarke stated that this was his favourite. Prior to the publishing of the novel, Clarke also wrote a short step outline with the same title, published in Omni magazine and anthologised in The Sentinel in 1983.

                • Cover of Nemesis
                  Nemesis

                  Isaac Asimov · standalone novel · 1989

                  similar byspace colonizationscience fictionfar future+2 more

                  The expanding population and ensuing ecological degradation of Earth leads to the establishment of orbital habitats which continue to compete with each other as well as with Earth, leading one of them to abandon the Solar System entirely, to establish itself around a neighboring star.

                • Cover of The Martian Chronicles
                  The Martian Chronicles

                  series · 30 books · 1946

                  completed

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fiction+1 more

                  The Martian Chronicles (1950) is Ray Bradbury's fix-up novel, a chain of linked short stories following waves of settlers leaving a troubled Earth to colonize Mars and encountering its native Martians, before Earth itself is ultimately consumed by nuclear war.

                • Cover of Aurora
                  Aurora

                  Kim Stanley Robinson · standalone novel · 2015

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar futurehard science fiction

                  Aurora is a 2015 novel by American science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson. The novel concerns a generation ship built in the style of a Stanford torus, traveling to Tau Ceti to start a human colony. The novel's primary narrative voice is that of the starship's artificial intelligence. Aurora was well received by critics.

                • Cover of Rite of Passage
                  Rite of Passage

                  Alexei Panshin · standalone novel · 1968

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar future

                  Rite of Passage is a science fiction novel by American writer Alexei Panshin. Published in 1968 as an Ace Science Fiction Special, this novel about a shipboard teenager's coming of age won that year's Nebula Award, and was nominated for the Hugo Award for Best Novel in 1969.

                • Cover of Destiny's Road
                  Destiny's Road

                  Larry Niven · standalone novel · 1997

                  similar byspace colonizationscience fictionfar futurehard science fiction+1 more

                  Destiny's Road is a science fiction novel by American writer Larry Niven, first published in 1998. It follows Jemmy Bloocher's exploration of Destiny's Road, a long scar of once-melted rock seared onto the planet's surface by a spaceship's fusion drive. Jemmy is descended from the original Destiny colonists, who were stranded when their landing craft deserted them.

                • Cover of Remnant Population
                  Remnant Population

                  Elizabeth Moon · standalone novel · 1996

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar future+1 more

                  From the dust jacket front flap of the Baen first edition: Alone at last... People had always told Ofelia what to do; for once she was going to do what she wanted. She refused to get on the cryo ships, refused to leave the only world she could call home. And when they finally came for her, she hid, not that the authorities looked all that hard for one crazy old woman. Now Ofelia is alone, content to live with no more demands on her self or her time, the only remaining settler on an abandoned planet. The new settlers arrive. At first she fears that they have come to reoccupy the settlement she has come to think of as hers - but they land far away. And as Ofelia secretly listens, they are slaughtered to the last child by stone-age aliens no one knew were there. Now it will be up to Ofelia to save the aliens from Earth's wrath...

                • Cover of Helliconia
                  Helliconia

                  series · 4 books · 1982

                  completed

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar future

                  The Helliconia trilogy is a series of science fiction books by British writer Brian W. Aldiss, set on the Earth-like planet Helliconia. It is an epic chronicling the rise and fall of a civilisation over thousands of years as the planet progresses through its incredibly long seasons, which last for centuries.

                • Cover of The Face of the Waters
                  The Face of the Waters

                  Robert Silverberg · standalone novel · 1991

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar future

                  On the ocean world of Hydros -- a planet with no land beyond a scatter of artificial floating islands -- the human settlers of Sorve commit an offense against the native aquatic Hydrans serious enough to get their community banished, forbidden from settling on any other island. With nowhere else to go, Sorve's people set out across the water in a makeshift flotilla, chasing rumors of a mythical island called the Face of the Waters that may or may not exist, forced to reckon with what they owe the world they've spent generations treating as theirs. A Robert Silverberg novel of exile and search, told through Sorve's displaced islanders.

                • Cover of Building Harlequin's Moon
                  Building Harlequin's Moon

                  Larry Niven & Brenda Cooper · standalone novel · 2005

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar futurehard science fiction

                  The first interstellar starship, John Glenn, fled a Solar System populated by rogue AIs and machine/human hybrids, threatened by too much nanotechnology and rife with political dangers. The John Glenn’s crew intended to terraform the nearly pristine planet Ymir, in hopes of creating a utopian society that will limit intelligent technology. But by some miscalculation they have landed in another solar system, and extremely low on the antimatter needed to continue to Ymir, they must shape the nearby planet Harlequin’s moon, Selene, into a new, temporary home. Their only hope of ever reaching Ymir is to rebuild their store of antimatter through decades of terraforming the moon. Gabriel, the head terraformer, must lead this nearly impossible task, with all the wrong materials. His primary tools are the uneducated and nearly illiterate children of the original colonists, born and bred to build Harlequin’s moon into a virtual antimatter factory. With no concept of the future and with life defined as duty, one girl, Rachel Vanowen, begins to ask herself the question: what will become of the children of Selene once the terraforming is complete.

                • Cover of Learning the World
                  Learning the World

                  Ken MacLeod · standalone novel · 2005

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar futurehard science fiction

                  From the front flap of the Tor first printing: "Humanity has spread to every star within 500 light-years of its half-forgotten origin, coloring the sky with a haze of habitats. Societies rise and fall. Incautious experiments burn fast and fade. On the fringes, less modified humans get on with the job of settling a universe that has, so far, been empty of intelligent life. The ancient starship But the Sky, My Lady! The Sky! is entering orbit around a promising new system after a four hundred year journey. For its long-lived inhabitants, the centuries have been busy. Now a younger generation is eager to settle the system. The ship is a seed-pod ready to burst. Then they detect curious electromagnetic emissions from the system's Earth-like world. As the nature of the signals becomes clear, the choices facing the humans become stark. On Ground, second world from the sun, a young astronomer searches for his system's outermost planet. A moving point of light thrills, then disappoints him. It's only a comet. His physicist colleague Orro takes time off from trying to invent a flying-machine to calculate the comet's trajectory. Something is very odd about that comet's path. They are not the only ones for whom the world has changed. "We are not living in the universe we thought we lived in yesterday. We have to start learning the world all over again.""

                • Cover of The World at the End of Time
                  The World at the End of Time

                  Frederik Pohl · standalone novel · 1990

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar futurehard science fiction

                  World at the End of Time is a 1990 hard science fiction novel by American writer Frederik Pohl. It tells the parallel stories of a human and a plasma-based intelligence who manage to survive to the time near the heat death of the universe. The book is thus a combined work in speculative cosmology and space colonization.

                • Cover of Semiosis
                  Semiosis

                  series · 3 books · 2018

                  similar byspace colonizationscience fictionfar future+1 more

                  Semiosis is Sue Burke's science fiction trilogy: Semiosis (2018), Interference and Usurpation. It follows generations of human colonists on an alien world forming an uneasy, evolving relationship with Stevland, a highly intelligent sentient plant, as the colony's survival comes to depend on cooperating with a fundamentally non-animal intelligence. The trilogy follows one continuous colony's history across decades of story time.

                • Cover of Manseed
                  Manseed

                  Jack Williamson · standalone novel · 1982

                  similar byspace colonizationreflectivescience fictionfar future

                  In the decades since i've read this novel somehow i forgot almost everything about it, except the powerful force it had on me. However, the the following description from http://www.fictiondb.com/author/jack-williamson~manseed~117359~b.htm seems to match my long ago reading experience: Egan Drake was a wealthy but unhappy visionary who died early and left behind only a powerful dream. He proposed to spread Mankind among the stars. Then there was Megan Drake. She took her brother's vision and made it real. At the Raven Foundation's New Mexico headquarters, she gathered around her experts in astronautics, biology, computer science, defense, and fusion propulsion. The project was simple in design yet grandiose in its aim: a thousand tiny ships would crawl to the stars; each that landed on an Earth-type planet would produce several dozen colonists; each colonist would be a product of the genes derived from Megan and her experts. Every ship would manufacture cyborgs for repairs and self-protection. But much of the technology was new and untried; no one could predict what might really occur at a millennia-long journey's end if, say, a cyborg fell in love or aliens were met or...

                • Cover of Seed of Light
                  Seed of Light

                  Edmund Cooper · standalone novel · 1959

                  similar byspace colonizationscience fictionfar future+1 more

                  From the back cover of the Ballantine first edition: "The Solarian was a hundred metres high and, at its broadest point, twenty metres in diameter. It was designed to carry an initial crew of ten people - five men and five women - with provision for subsequent children. Yet in that vast hull every cubic metre of space was indispensable, for the ship was a self-contained world, required to support human life independently for centuries. No member of the crew, male or female, could regard themselves as a separate entity, an individual personality But each person was a part of a total life-unit, a dedicated nucleus that might one day expand into a tribe; that might, phoenixlike, bring forth a new human race."

                • Cover of Isis
                  Isis

                  series · 3 books · 1980

                  completed

                  similar byspace colonizationscience fictionfar future+1 more

                  The Keeper of the Isis Light, by Monica Hughes, opens a science-fiction trilogy for young readers set on the distant colony world of Isis, orbiting the star Ra, as new settlers from Earth arrive to find the planet already has a solitary young guardian who isn't glad to see them. The trilogy continues through The Guardian of Isis and The Isis Pedlar, later collected together as The Isis Trilogy.

                • Cover of Hainish
                  Hainish

                  series · 33 books · 1964

                  completed

                  similar byreflectivescience fictionfar future

                  The Hainish Cycle consists of a number of science fiction novels and stories by Ursula K. Le Guin. The cycle is set in a future history that features civilizations of human beings on planets orbiting a number of nearby stars, including Terra ("Earth"); these humans are contacting each other for the first time and establishing diplomatic relations, as well as setting up a confederacy under the guidance of the oldest of the human worlds, the peaceful planet Hain. In this history, human beings did not evolve on Earth, but they were instead the result of interstellar colonies planted by Hain in the distant past, after which interstellar travel ceased for an extended period. Some of the human races have new genetic traits, a result of ancient Hainish experiments in genetic engineering; this includes people who can dream while awake, and a world of hermaphroditic people who only enter active sexuality once per month, not knowing which sex will manifest in them. In keeping with Le Guin's narrative approach, she uses varied social and environmental settings to explore the anthropological and sociological outcomes of human evolution in those environments. The author often discounted the characterization of a so-called "Hainish Cycle".

                • Cover of Macrolife
                  Macrolife

                  series · 2 books · 1979

                  completed

                  similar byreflectivescience fictionfar future+2 more

                • Cover of Elysium Cycle
                  Elysium Cycle

                  series · 5 books · 1986

                  similar byscience fictionfar future+3 more

                  On the ocean-covered moon Shora, the Sharers -- an all-female society skilled in genetic engineering and committed to strict nonviolence -- face invasion by the militaristic Patriarchy, which cannot fathom a people who refuse to fight back with force. Joan Slonczewski's A Door into Ocean opens the Elysium Cycle by testing whether a philosophy built on the idea that 'to hurt is to be hurt' can actually survive violent occupation. Later books in the cycle, including Daughter of Elysium, The Children Star, and Brain Plague, carry the same interest in biology, pacifism, and alien societies into new settings.

                • Cover of The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress
                  The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress

                  Robert A. Heinlein · standalone novel · 1966

                  similar byspace colonizationscience fictionfar future

                  A technician discovers that the massive computer that operates everything on Luna (a prison colony) has become self-aware. He befriends it, but when he accompanied a beautiful girl to a dissident meeting, he encounters people who want to throw off the yoke of their Earth rulers.

                • Cover of People of the Sky
                  People of the Sky

                  Clare Bell · standalone novel · 1989

                  similar byspace colonizationscience fictionfar future+1 more

                  From the flaps of the Tor first edition: "...Clare Bell has created the wonderfully strange and fascinating Oneway, where humans and Aronans, the graceful alien flyers their human partners need for survival in their village at the bottom of the deep Barranca "mother canyon" live in symbiotic harmony. It is two hundred years since Pueblo Indians followed the prophecy of the miraculous Blue Star Kachina that appeared during a ritual on ancient holy ground in the American Southwest. Funded by the tribe's endowment, a faction of the Pueblo tribe emigrated to the far star of the prophecy and found Oneway, a planet of plateaus and canyons like their native Southwest. Now, two hundred years later, the colony of the Pai Yinaye, "People of the Sky," as they call themselves, is only a legend to those who live in Oneway's high-tech enclaves. Kesbe Temiya, a restorer of antique aircraft, discovers the lost colony when her plane is forced down in a storm over the Barranca. Kesbe, herself the daughter of American Pueblo Indians, had been delivering a "Gooney Bird" - a World War II C-47 transport plane which had been stranded and preserved on the ice of a Greenland glacier - to its new owner at an airbase on Oneway. Rescued by a villager and his Aronan, she is taken to the isolated Pai village where the People, wary of outsiders, won't help her unless she accepts their traditions by undergoing the initiation rites, including bonding with her own Aronan. Nobody outside the tribe, not even a Pueblo like Kesbo, has ever undergone the intense ordeal of initiation. Before she is accepted, Kesbo's life will be transformed by the unique and alien experience that sets apart the Pai..."