More like Which Witch Is Which?

anchored on:north americacontemporarysmall town

but

Narrow

Good OmensSeries
series2 books1990
Humor and fantasy, about prophecy, set in british isles.
Start with Good Omens: The Nice and Accurate Prophecies of Agnes Nutter, Witch →
Fix-It WitchesSeries
series4 books2021
About witches, set in contemporary.
“After a toxic ex and too much magical family meddling, she's made a pact to keep her heart—and her spellwork—off-limits.”
from the catalogue
Start with Witch Please →
Half Moon HollowUniverse
universe17 books2009
About vampires.
“The world opens on Jane Jameson, a children's librarian who is fired, mistaken for a deer and shot in a parking lot, then revived as a vampire, all in one spectacularly bad night.”
from the catalogue
Start with Nice Girls Don't Have Fangs →
includes Jane Jameson, Nice Girl Spin-Offs, Gigi Scanlon, Libby Stratton
The Witches of Port TownsendSeries
series4 books2014
Set in contemporary and small town.
Start with Which Witch Is Which? →
Magic in Manhattan (Sarah Mlynowski)Series
series4 books2005
About coming of age.
“Blink your eyes, drink a fizzing pink potion, and poof!”
from the catalogue
Start with Bras & Broomsticks →
Caster Chronicles / Beautiful Creatures UniverseSeries
series8 books2009
Fantasy.
Start with Beautiful Creatures →