Series

Books like Starry Hollow Witches: 9 series to read next

Starry Hollow Witches is set in contemporary. The 9 series below are ranked by how much of that they share — each card says which parts.

Starry Hollow Witches is 20 books, 2017–2024.

The Starry Hollow Witches page →Narrow this list →

Magical Bakery Mystery
Perfectly Proper Paranormal Museum Mysteries
Witch Way Librarian Mysteries
Bewitching Mysteries
Myrtlewood Mysteries
Witch City Mysteries
Chintz 'n China
Southern Witch
Magic & Mixology Mystery

Magical Bakery MysterySeries

seriesBailey Cates10 books2012

Cozy mystery, about murder investigation, set in contemporary and small town.

“Katie Lightfoot's tired of loafing around as the assistant manager of an Ohio bakery.”
from the catalogue description of Brownies and Broomsticks

Start with Brownies and Broomsticks →

Perfectly Proper Paranormal Museum MysteriesSeries

seriesKirsten Weiss6 books2016

Cozy mystery and paranormal, set in contemporary.

Start with The Perfectly Proper Paranormal Museum →

Witch Way Librarian MysteriesSeries

seriesAngela M. Sanders8 books2020

Cozy mystery, set in contemporary.

“Librarian Josie Way moved to small-town Oregon to lay low.”
from the catalogue description of Bait and Witch

Start with Bait and Witch →

Bewitching MysteriesSeries

seriesMadelyn Alt7 books2006

Cozy mystery, mysterious in tone, about murder investigation and witches, set in contemporary and small town.

“A Bewitching mystery--first in the new paranormal chick-lit mystery seriesAntiques-shop clerk Maggie O'Neill was a little weirded out when she discovered her new boss Felicity was a witch.”
from the catalogue description of The Trouble with Magic

Start with The Trouble with Magic →

Myrtlewood MysteriesSeries

seriesIris Beaglehole8 books2022

Urban fantasy, about witches, set in contemporary and small town.

“Welcome to Myrtlewood, a quirky town, steeped in magic, tea, and mystery… Life’s a struggle for Rosemary Thorn and her teen daughter, Athena.”
from the catalogue description of Accidental Magic

Start with Accidental Magic →

Witch City MysteriesSeries

seriesCarol J. Perry15 books2014

Cozy mystery, set in contemporary.

“Most folks associate the city of Salem, Massachusetts with witches, but for Lee Barrett, it's home.”
from the catalogue description of Caught Dead Handed

Start with Caught Dead Handed →

Chintz 'n ChinaSeries

seriesYasmine Galenorn7 books2003

Mysterious in tone, set in contemporary.

“Emerald O'Brien is the owner of the Chintz 'n China Tea Room where guests are served the perfect blend of tea and tarot reading.”
from the catalogue description of Ghost of a Chance

Start with Ghost of a Chance →

Southern WitchSeries

seriesKimberly Frost5 books2009

Urban fantasy, about witches, set in contemporary and small town.

“The promising debut of a hot new voice in paranormal romance—and the first of the Southern Witch novels.The family magic seems to have skipped over Tammy Jo Trask.”
from the catalogue description of Would-Be Witch

Start with Would-Be Witch →

Magic & Mixology MysterySeries

seriesGina LaManna8 books2016

Cozy mystery, set in contemporary.

Start with Hex on the Beach →

Why these

No sales rank, no star ratings, no readers also bought.

Shared terms are not a promise that a book feels the same. Two series can be far-future political intrigue and read nothing alike — what the ranking can say is what they are about, and each card says which parts it shares.

Questions readers ask

What should I read after Starry Hollow Witches?: Magical Bakery Mystery — the closest match to Starry Hollow Witches on what it is about, not on what sells.
Where do I start with Starry Hollow Witches?: Magic & Murder. It is the entry the catalogue recommends for Starry Hollow Witches.
How big is Starry Hollow Witches?: Starry Hollow Witches is 20 books, 2017–2024.

Books like Starry Hollow Witches: 9 series to read next

Read next in Starry Hollow Witches

Why these

Questions readers ask

Other series like this one